2D Paintball
Loading _
Patreon!
players in game Spectate
To play 2DPaintball, open this website on a compatible desktop web browser with a mouse & keyboard.

has started!

You are registered for this tournament.
Click to Join the Tournament Field
View brackets on the tournament page.

Ranked Matchmaking is started!

You are in a ranked match event!
Join back now in the matchmaking field!

Pro 7v7 👀

Ninjaball E4 by goldygoldy
5 - 0
Final Score
Place Score Player Kills Deaths K/D Ratio Rank Level
#1 310 WalmartPillows1 17 5 3.4 Un-ranked 52
#2 212 Bot - 8 3 1 3 N/A 0
#3 201 Bot - 10 2 0 2 N/A 0
#4 161 Bot - 4 7 2 3.5 N/A 0
#5 157 Bot - 12 2 2 1 N/A 0
#6 156 Bot - 6 2 2 1 N/A 0
#7 155 Bot - 2 2 2 1 N/A 0
#8 51 Bot - 13 4 5 0.8 N/A 0
#9 42 Bot - 5 3 5 0.6 N/A 0
#10 20 Bot - 1 2 5 0.4 N/A 0
#11 20 Bot - 11 2 5 0.4 N/A 0
#12 15 Bot - 3 1 5 0.2 N/A 0
#13 11 Bot - 7 1 5 0.2 N/A 0
#14 10 Bot - 9 1 5 0.2 N/A 0
Campaign

2D Paintball Match Log #645948 (05-07-2023 @ 11:01pm)

Round #1 Recap Round length: 0:44 / Team Red Scored

Bot - 1 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 141 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 181.5 ft.
Bot - 2 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 22 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 148.3 ft.
Bot - 3 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 81 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 189.6 ft.
Bot - 4 Got 2 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 240 shots Reloads 1 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 241.4 ft.
Bot - 5 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 276 shots Reloads 1 Chops 1 Swabs 1 Ran 199.1 ft.
WalmartPillows1 Got 3 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 198 shots Reloads 1 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 307.5 ft.
Bot - 6 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 317 shots Reloads 1 Chops 2 Swabs 1 Ran 223.8 ft.
Bot - 7 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 170 shots Reloads 0 Chops 1 Swabs 1 Ran 214 ft.
Bot - 8 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 11 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 150 ft.
Bot - 9 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 86 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 168.7 ft.
Bot - 10 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 32 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 134.1 ft.
Bot - 11 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 22 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 117.4 ft.
Bot - 12 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 243 shots Reloads 1 Chops 1 Swabs 1 Ran 248.9 ft.
Bot - 13 Got 2 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 30 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 164.7 ft.

Round #1 Event log

Bot - 8 Was eliminated @ 1.61
Bot - 13 Got a kill @ 1.61
Bot - 5 Chopped a ball @ 2.49
Bot - 11 Was eliminated @ 2.52
Bot - 12 Got a kill @ 2.52
Bot - 13 Was eliminated @ 3.50
Bot - 10 Got a kill @ 3.50
Bot - 13 Got a kill @ 4.05
WalmartPillows1 Was eliminated @ 4.05
Bot - 2 Was eliminated @ 4.43
Bot - 9 Got a kill @ 4.43
Bot - 5 Swabbed @ 4.90
Bot - 12 Chopped a ball @ 4.90
WalmartPillows1 Took over bot @ 6.27
Bot - 12 Swabbed @ 9.80
Bot - 7 Chopped a ball @ 10.38
Bot - 3 Was eliminated @ 12.94
Bot - 4 Got a kill @ 12.94
Bot - 7 Swabbed @ 14.01
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 16.76
Bot - 9 Was eliminated @ 16.76
WalmartPillows1 Hit a • bonus ball @ 16.81
Bot - 9 Got • bonus balled @ 16.81
Bot - 1 Was eliminated @ 19.38
Bot - 4 Got a kill @ 19.38
Bot - 5 Reloaded @ 24.65
Bot - 6 Reloaded @ 25.64
Bot - 6 Chopped a ball @ 32.90
Bot - 4 Reloaded @ 33.49
Bot - 7 Was eliminated @ 34.75
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 34.75
Bot - 6 Swabbed @ 35.48
Bot - 12 Reloaded @ 35.73
WalmartPillows1 Reloaded @ 37.13
Bot - 6 Chopped a ball @ 40.82
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 44.14
Bot - 5 Was eliminated @ 44.14
WalmartPillows1 Hit a • bonus ball @ 44.21
Bot - 5 Got • bonus balled @ 44.21
Bot - 5 Got a kill @ 44.34
WalmartPillows1 Was eliminated @ 44.34
Bot - 5 Got the trade @ 44.34
WalmartPillows1 Traded out @ 44.34
Round Ended @ 44.39

Round #2 Recap Round length: 0:19 / Team Red Scored

Bot - 1 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 99 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 193.7 ft.
Bot - 2 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 79 shots Reloads 0 Chops 2 Swabs 1 Ran 177.2 ft.
Bot - 3 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 83 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 168.8 ft.
Bot - 4 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 120 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 154.5 ft.
Bot - 5 Got 0 kills Took 1 bounces Fired 23 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 135.1 ft.
WalmartPillows1 Got 3 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 95 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 272.4 ft.
Bot - 6 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 101 shots Reloads 0 Chops 1 Swabs 0 Ran 179.5 ft.
Bot - 7 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 76 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 136.1 ft.
Bot - 8 Got 2 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 107 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 181 ft.
Bot - 9 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 16 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 157.8 ft.
Bot - 10 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 126 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 155 ft.
Bot - 11 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 4 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 137.6 ft.
Bot - 12 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 17 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 147.1 ft.
Bot - 13 Got 2 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 114 shots Reloads 0 Chops 1 Swabs 0 Ran 167.2 ft.

Round #2 Event log

Bot - 11 Was eliminated @ 0.99
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 0.99
Bot - 9 Was eliminated @ 2.02
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 2.02
Bot - 2 Chopped a ball @ 2.32
Bot - 12 Was eliminated @ 3.20
Bot - 13 Got a kill @ 3.20
Bot - 8 Bounced • a player @ 4.19
Bot - 5 Took a • bounce @ 4.19
Bot - 5 Was eliminated @ 4.20
Bot - 8 Got a kill @ 4.20
Bot - 2 Chopped a ball @ 4.82
Bot - 2 Swabbed @ 8.88
Bot - 4 Got a kill @ 9.12
Bot - 7 Was eliminated @ 9.12
Bot - 3 Was eliminated @ 9.97
Bot - 8 Got a kill @ 9.97
Bot - 1 Was eliminated @ 11.47
Bot - 6 Got a kill @ 11.47
Bot - 13 Chopped a ball @ 14.78
Bot - 13 Was eliminated @ 18.59
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 18.59
Bot - 6 Chopped a ball @ 18.92
WalmartPillows1 Was eliminated @ 18.94
Bot - 13 Got a kill @ 18.94
WalmartPillows1 Traded out @ 18.94
Bot - 13 Got the trade @ 18.94
Round Ended @ 19.01

Round #3 Recap Round length: 0:28 / Team Red Scored

Bot - 1 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 17 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 158.4 ft.
Bot - 2 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 77 shots Reloads 0 Chops 1 Swabs 0 Ran 173 ft.
Bot - 3 Got 1 kills Took 1 bounces Fired 68 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 151 ft.
Bot - 4 Got 2 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 73 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 174.3 ft.
Bot - 5 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 15 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 155.5 ft.
WalmartPillows1 Got 4 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 135 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 190.2 ft.
Bot - 6 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 98 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 199.9 ft.
Bot - 7 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 93 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 163.9 ft.
Bot - 8 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 52 shots Reloads 0 Chops 1 Swabs 1 Ran 183.2 ft.
Bot - 9 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 2 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 134.8 ft.
Bot - 10 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 81 shots Reloads 0 Chops 1 Swabs 1 Ran 170.4 ft.
Bot - 11 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 126 shots Reloads 0 Chops 1 Swabs 1 Ran 201 ft.
Bot - 12 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 72 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 220.8 ft.
Bot - 13 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 29 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 162.1 ft.

Round #3 Event log

Bot - 9 Was eliminated @ 0.85
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 0.85
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 1.87
Bot - 5 Was eliminated @ 1.87
Bot - 1 Was eliminated @ 2.16
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 2.16
Bot - 1 Got • bonus balled @ 2.29
Bot - 4 Hit a • bonus ball @ 2.29
Bot - 8 Chopped a ball @ 2.39
Bot - 10 Chopped a ball @ 2.69
Bot - 13 Was eliminated @ 3.98
Bot - 4 Got a kill @ 3.98
Bot - 10 Swabbed @ 6.63
Bot - 8 Swabbed @ 7.93
WalmartPillows1 Bounced • a player @ 8.21
Bot - 3 Took a • bounce @ 8.21
Bot - 2 Chopped a ball @ 10.07
Bot - 4 Got a kill @ 10.32
Bot - 3 Was eliminated @ 10.32
Bot - 3 Got a kill @ 10.40
WalmartPillows1 Was eliminated @ 10.40
Bot - 11 Chopped a ball @ 11.22
WalmartPillows1 Took over bot @ 12.06
Bot - 2 Was eliminated @ 14.83
Bot - 11 Got a kill @ 14.83
Bot - 7 Was eliminated @ 14.90
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 14.90
Bot - 11 Swabbed @ 15.18
Bot - 10 Got a kill @ 27.78
Bot - 11 Was eliminated @ 27.78
Round Ended @ 28.20

Round #4 Recap Round length: 0:18 / Team Red Scored

Bot - 1 Got 0 kills Took 1 bounces Fired 7 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 142.8 ft.
Bot - 2 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 124 shots Reloads 0 Chops 1 Swabs 1 Ran 148.1 ft.
Bot - 3 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 17 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 127.2 ft.
Bot - 4 Got 2 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 13 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 152.5 ft.
Bot - 5 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 136 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 182.2 ft.
WalmartPillows1 Got 2 kills Took 1 bounces Fired 223 shots Reloads 1 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 84 ft.
Bot - 6 Got 1 kills Took 1 bounces Fired 71 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 190 ft.
Bot - 7 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 17 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 159 ft.
Bot - 8 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 142 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 176 ft.
Bot - 9 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 9 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 141.5 ft.
Bot - 10 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 93 shots Reloads 0 Chops 1 Swabs 1 Ran 151 ft.
Bot - 11 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 59 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 161.1 ft.
Bot - 12 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 127 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 179.5 ft.
Bot - 13 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 103 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 136.6 ft.

Round #4 Event log

Bot - 1 Took a • bounce @ 1.26
WalmartPillows1 Bounced • a player @ 1.26
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 1.28
Bot - 1 Was eliminated @ 1.28
Bot - 4 Was eliminated @ 1.86
Bot - 7 Got a kill @ 1.86
Bot - 6 Got a kill @ 2.02
Bot - 9 Was eliminated @ 2.02
Bot - 4 Got • bonus balled @ 2.03
Bot - 7 Hit a • bonus ball @ 2.03
Bot - 4 Got a kill @ 2.15
Bot - 7 Was eliminated @ 2.15
Bot - 4 Got the trade @ 2.15
Bot - 7 Traded out @ 2.15
Bot - 3 Was eliminated @ 2.17
Bot - 4 Got a kill @ 2.17
Bot - 10 Hit a • bonus ball @ 2.35
Bot - 9 Got • bonus balled @ 2.35
Bot - 10 Chopped a ball @ 3.51
Bot - 10 Swabbed @ 7.78
Bot - 5 Got a kill @ 9.23
Bot - 6 Was eliminated @ 9.23
Bot - 6 Got • bonus balled @ 9.51
Bot - 13 Hit a • bonus ball @ 9.51
WalmartPillows1 Reloaded @ 10.30
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 11.79
Bot - 11 Was eliminated @ 11.79
WalmartPillows1 Hit a • bonus ball @ 11.83
Bot - 11 Got • bonus balled @ 11.83
Bot - 2 Chopped a ball @ 12.37
Bot - 13 Was eliminated @ 13.66
Bot - 2 Got a kill @ 13.66
Bot - 2 Swabbed @ 15.13
Bot - 12 Got a kill @ 18.68
Bot - 5 Was eliminated @ 18.68
Bot - 5 Got • bonus balled @ 18.76
Bot - 12 Hit a • bonus ball @ 18.76
Bot - 12 Hit a • bonus ball @ 18.79
Bot - 5 Got • bonus balled @ 18.79
Bot - 5 Bounced • a player @ 18.79
WalmartPillows1 Took a • bounce @ 18.79
Round Ended @ 18.88

Round #5 Recap Round length: 1:07 / Team Red Scored

Bot - 1 Got 2 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 311 shots Reloads 1 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 249.4 ft.
Bot - 2 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 365 shots Reloads 2 Chops 1 Swabs 1 Ran 291 ft.
Bot - 3 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 493 shots Reloads 3 Chops 3 Swabs 3 Ran 254.4 ft.
Bot - 4 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 86 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 173.9 ft.
Bot - 5 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 117 shots Reloads 0 Chops 2 Swabs 1 Ran 174.1 ft.
WalmartPillows1 Got 5 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 426 shots Reloads 3 Chops 1 Swabs 1 Ran 294.6 ft.
Bot - 6 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 199 shots Reloads 1 Chops 1 Swabs 1 Ran 204.3 ft.
Bot - 7 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 57 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 169.3 ft.
Bot - 8 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 375 shots Reloads 2 Chops 4 Swabs 3 Ran 325.7 ft.
Bot - 9 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 12 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 150.8 ft.
Bot - 10 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 447 shots Reloads 2 Chops 3 Swabs 3 Ran 251 ft.
Bot - 11 Got 1 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 389 shots Reloads 2 Chops 3 Swabs 3 Ran 264.8 ft.
Bot - 12 Got 0 kills Took 1 bounces Fired 25 shots Reloads 0 Chops 0 Swabs 0 Ran 160.6 ft.
Bot - 13 Got 0 kills Took 0 bounces Fired 160 shots Reloads 0 Chops 1 Swabs 1 Ran 187.7 ft.

Round #5 Event log

Bot - 10 Chopped a ball @ 0.42
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 1.90
Bot - 9 Was eliminated @ 1.90
Bot - 9 Got • bonus balled @ 1.97
WalmartPillows1 Hit a • bonus ball @ 1.97
WalmartPillows1 Hit a • bonus ball @ 1.97
Bot - 9 Got • bonus balled @ 1.97
Bot - 3 Chopped a ball @ 2.61
Bot - 8 Chopped a ball @ 2.95
Bot - 10 Swabbed @ 3.36
Bot - 12 Was eliminated @ 3.53
Bot - 1 Got a kill @ 3.53
Bot - 12 Got • bonus balled @ 3.89
Bot - 5 Hit a • bonus ball @ 3.89
Bot - 3 Swabbed @ 5.75
Bot - 5 Chopped a ball @ 7.18
Bot - 8 Swabbed @ 7.67
Bot - 7 Was eliminated @ 10.63
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 10.63
WalmartPillows1 Chopped a ball @ 10.70
WalmartPillows1 Hit a • bonus ball @ 10.70
Bot - 7 Got • bonus balled @ 10.70
Bot - 7 Got • bonus balled @ 10.72
Bot - 6 Hit a • bonus ball @ 10.72
Bot - 5 Swabbed @ 11.32
Bot - 4 Was eliminated @ 11.77
Bot - 11 Got a kill @ 11.77
WalmartPillows1 Swabbed @ 12.52
Bot - 11 Chopped a ball @ 13.40
Bot - 8 Chopped a ball @ 13.45
Bot - 13 Chopped a ball @ 13.71
WalmartPillows1 Reloaded @ 14.08
Bot - 8 Swabbed @ 16.02
Bot - 13 Swabbed @ 16.29
Bot - 11 Swabbed @ 17.22
Bot - 5 Chopped a ball @ 18.25
Bot - 10 Chopped a ball @ 19.74
Bot - 5 Was eliminated @ 20.11
Bot - 8 Got a kill @ 20.11
Bot - 5 Got • bonus balled @ 20.14
Bot - 8 Hit a • bonus ball @ 20.14
Bot - 8 Hit a • bonus ball @ 20.24
Bot - 5 Got • bonus balled @ 20.24
Bot - 10 Swabbed @ 22.18
Bot - 3 Reloaded @ 23.64
Bot - 10 Reloaded @ 24.31
Bot - 2 Chopped a ball @ 24.70
Bot - 6 Chopped a ball @ 24.77
Bot - 1 Reloaded @ 25.49
Bot - 6 Swabbed @ 28.07
Bot - 2 Swabbed @ 29.03
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 29.71
Bot - 13 Was eliminated @ 29.71
Bot - 13 Got • bonus balled @ 29.81
WalmartPillows1 Hit a • bonus ball @ 29.81
WalmartPillows1 Reloaded @ 29.84
Bot - 13 Got • bonus balled @ 29.84
WalmartPillows1 Hit a • bonus ball @ 29.84
Bot - 11 Reloaded @ 30.20
Bot - 6 Reloaded @ 30.26
Bot - 8 Reloaded @ 30.92
Bot - 6 Was eliminated @ 32.89
Bot - 1 Got a kill @ 32.89
Bot - 2 Reloaded @ 33.02
Bot - 3 Chopped a ball @ 34.03
Bot - 11 Chopped a ball @ 34.85
Bot - 3 Swabbed @ 37.22
Bot - 11 Swabbed @ 39.26
Bot - 3 Reloaded @ 42.09
Bot - 10 Reloaded @ 42.57
Bot - 8 Chopped a ball @ 44.45
Bot - 8 Swabbed @ 47.93
Bot - 10 Chopped a ball @ 48.07
Bot - 1 Was eliminated @ 49.02
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 49.02
WalmartPillows1 Hit a • bonus ball @ 49.34
Bot - 1 Got • bonus balled @ 49.34
Bot - 11 Chopped a ball @ 51.15
Bot - 10 Swabbed @ 51.83
Bot - 11 Reloaded @ 52.64
Bot - 8 Reloaded @ 53.99
Bot - 3 Chopped a ball @ 54.38
Bot - 11 Swabbed @ 55.02
WalmartPillows1 Reloaded @ 55.36
Bot - 3 Swabbed @ 59.13
Bot - 2 Reloaded @ 59.17
Bot - 8 Chopped a ball @ 61.23
Bot - 3 Reloaded @ 62.80
Bot - 2 Got a kill @ 63.53
Bot - 11 Was eliminated @ 63.53
WalmartPillows1 Got a kill @ 67.23
Bot - 3 Was eliminated @ 67.23
Round Ended @ 67.67

Alpha Testing

Bugs: The game is in alpha. This means random issues may occur (server freezing, rogue bots, and general mayhem.) If you run into any issues, please be patient and send some feedback through our Feedback Button , this will help us track and fix the issues as fast as possible.

Lag: Currently the game is very ping dependent for smoothness in gameplay. If you get 150+ ping to the server, have bad internet, are streaming/downloading anything in the background (or if anyone on your network is) you may have a degraded playing experience (stuttering/lag)
The gameplay should feel perfectly smooth if you get <= 90ms Ping with 60+ FPS (Refer to netgraph at top right of in-game screen.)

Features: During alpha, features, interfaces, systems, and gameplay mechanics may change drastically. We incourage suggestions and Feedback